Skip to main content

Florida State would be doing the smart thing by avoiding Jimbo Fisher

It might be an option that makes tons of sense financially, but Fisher brings with him issues Florida State cannot deal with at the moment.
ByJarrett Guerrera
The ACC Huddle pregame show kicks off on the campus of Florida State University and features former FSU head coach Jimbo Fisher. Several fans in the background hold signs reading “bring back Jimbo” and “some legends hit different.”
The ACC Huddle pregame show kicks off on the campus of Florida State University and features former FSU head coach Jimbo Fisher. Several fans in the background hold signs reading “bring back Jimbo” and “some legends hit different.” | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

At this point, there have been plenty of rumors connecting Florida State to Jimbo Fisher, but the former coach may not be as big a candidate for the open job as he once was. Fisher brings plenty of experience to the table, and at a discount price, but there is also a past that the coach cannot outrun.

Years after a failed run with Texas A&M that resulted in a historic $77.5 million buyout being triggered, Fisher has been throwing his hat back into the ring in an effort to coach again. Fisher went 42-25 with the Aggies, including a record of 27-21 against SEC competition. Fisher lost fewer than three conference games once in 2020, which also happened to be the only season where the team was ranked inside the top ten programs.

A successful tenure with Florida State often makes Seminoles' fans forget exactly what went wrong with the Aggies that resulted in Fisher hitting the curb. The difference, however, is that the administration likely understands this, and Florida State needs to realize just how bad a decision bringing back Fisher would be.

Florida State cannot afford to mess up the next hire, and Fisher has too many red flags

For all of the fans out there that want to remember the good times with Fisher, you also need to remember that the coach once left the program in disarray to join the Aggies for what was, at the time, considered to be a better job. Fisher never managed to really get the Aggies off the ground, and the Seminoles have still not necessarily recovered yet.

The administration is putting a lot of attention into hiring the right fit moving forward, and the chaotic nature of Fisher is something that will work against him. Fisher can be a fun guy to listen to at times, but he has had his fair share of problems with the media and plenty of spats behind the scenes with his players. There is no exact mold for the characteristics Florida State is looking for in the next coach, but it is clear that Fisher is not going to meet that criteria.

A possible reunion between Florida State and Deion Sanders was something that floated around briefly, but the Seminoles appear uninterested in bringing Sanders in as the coach because of his attitude towards the media and the off-field chaos that has surrounded Colorado. If Florida State is unwilling to deal with Sanders for those reasons, it seems unlikely that Fisher would get a second chance.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

The idea of Fisher becoming a serious candidate seems even more unlikely when considering the friction that was created ahead of his original departure. Fisher wants to get back into coaching, but has not been connected to any of the smaller openings, or realistically, any of the current openings in general. If Fisher were hired once again, he could use any potential success with the program as a springboard for his career as he previously did.

Can Florida State teach an old dog new tricks?

I may have been a bit harsh on Fisher in the past in regard to NIL, but the reality is that you cannot fully understand the complexities of how the budget works and how the entire process has evolved unless you are in the thick of it.

Perhaps the biggest issue Florida State would need to work around with Fisher involves the world of NIL and roster budgeting, which needs a serious overhaul in Tallahassee. Fisher has been on the sidelines for a bit as the NIL landscape continues to rapidly change, and with or without an increased roster budget, the next coach needs to find a way to work with his resources in an extremely efficient manner.

Florida State dug itself into a hole heading into the season by putting an emphasis on retention, which resulted in limited funds for the portal. Additionally, Florida State did not spread the wealth whatsoever, with some positions like running back receiving a heavier investment than multiple positions combined.

It is no secret that Fisher will be bringing boatloads of cash with him, but the problem is that if he doesn't use the money right, the team is back to square one in the fight to become more competitive in NIL. Fisher lost over 40 players to the transfer portal, with less than 20 additions to make up for the losses, and most of the players who left were former high school recruits. There was a lot more than went into Fisher's downfall with Texas A&M, and the culture was what suffered the most.

Florida State has long tried to deny the presence of the "suck tax" despite clear evidence at this point, but there is also a culture tax that goes beyond wins and losses. Fisher has not exactly been anyone's best friend as a coach, which is only going to drive up the cost of some of the recruits who are interested in joining the program.

There has long been the argument that Fisher would be the ultimate combination of experience and reduced contract costs. While it might be true that he would be a cheaper hire, that has only been made possible by his disastrous firing and monster buyout. Glenn Schumann would be equally as cheap of a hire, but would have a much better understanding of how to operate the budget after spending time with Georgia, who have been one of the leaders in the NIL world.

Add us as a preferred source on Google